Collection: Always Menu

Welcome to the heart of Sarah’s Cookie Jar. These are our "Always Menu" staples — the fan favorites and best-sellers that you can find at the bakery any day of the week.

Whether you’re craving a classic Chocolate Chip, the nostalgia of a Dunkaroo, or our signature SCJ cookie, these flavors are baked daily and ready for you (unless we’ve sold out for the day!).

Find your forever favorite below.